Your eyes and hands in India · Est. 2019 · Replies within one working day

What penalty clauses should a tile purchase contract include?

Cover late shipment, wrong grade, mixed shade or calibre, short quantity, bad packing and document errors. Make each remedy clear, proportionate and easy to measure.

· 3 min read · Creston & Co

A tile purchase contract should set a clear remedy for each failure that actually costs you money: late shipment, wrong grade, mixed shade or calibre, short quantity, damage from poor packing, and document errors. Each clause should say how the failure is measured, what the factory owes and how it is paid.

The aim is not to punish the factory. It is to make the cost of a failure predictable for both sides, so problems are settled quickly instead of argued about after the container lands.

The clauses that matter for tiles

These are the failures tile importers face most often, with the usual way contracts deal with each one:

  • Late shipment: an agreed amount for each week the goods ship after the agreed date, up to a cap, plus your right to cancel after a long delay.
  • Wrong grade: replacement, a credit, or the right to reject boxes that fall below the written grade definition.
  • Mixed shade or calibre: the factory replaces non-matching boxes or credits them, because they cannot be laid together.
  • Short quantity: credit at the contract price for every missing box, checked against the packing list and your arrival count.
  • Breakage caused by packing: replacement or credit where the cause is weak cartons, wrong pallets or poor loading.
  • Document errors: the factory pays costs caused by wrong invoices, codes or certificates, such as storage or re-issue charges.
  • Deviation from the approved sample: the right to reject, or a credit agreed in advance.

Make each clause measurable

A penalty clause works only if both sides can agree when it applies. Tie each one to something you can check. Late shipment is measured by the bill of lading date. Grade and shade are measured against the written grade definition and the approved sample. Quantity is measured against the packing list and the arrival count.

Name the evidence in the contract: an independent pre-shipment inspection report, loading photos and an arrival report with photos. What a tile pre-shipment inspection report should include and how to make a breakage claim describe the evidence each side will rely on.

Keep remedies proportionate

In many legal systems, courts will not enforce an amount that works as a punishment rather than compensation. Under India's Contract Act, section 74, a party can recover reasonable compensation up to the amount named in the contract, not automatically the full amount. Other countries have their own rules. A clause that is clearly linked to your likely loss is easier to enforce.

Proportionate clauses are also easier to agree. A factory will sign a reasonable late-delivery clause with a cap. It will resist, or quietly price in, an open-ended one.

Payment terms are your strongest remedy

A clause in a contract is only as good as your ability to collect. If you have paid in full before shipment, recovering a penalty from a factory in another country is slow. If the balance is still unpaid until the inspection is accepted, the factory has a reason to settle. See the safest payment terms for tile imports.

Also agree how disputes are decided. Many international contracts choose arbitration, with a named seat and rules, because awards are enforceable in most countries under the New York Convention. Ask a lawyer in your market to review the final wording.

Next step

We help you set grade definitions, approved samples and inspection points that make these clauses workable, and we provide the inspection and loading evidence. For a longer relationship, see what a long-term supply agreement should include. To review your contract terms, book a free sourcing review.

More from the blog

Free · 20 minutes · No obligation

Start with a free 20-minute sourcing call.

Tell us the product, the spec and the volume. We'll tell you what it should cost from India, what to test for and where the risks are. No fee, no obligation, and you keep the notes.